8 Best Blackstone Replacement Griddle Tops (November 2026)
The best Blackstone 28 inch replacement griddle tops include the OZG 28" Premium Silicone Griddle Mat for storage protection, the Flybold 28 Inch Blackstone Griddle Hard Cover for a lightweight cover, and the Barbqtime 28 Inch Griddle Replacement Top for listed 28 inch models.
On this page (4 sections)
The best Blackstone replacement griddle top for many standard 28 inch models is the Stanbroil stainless steel top, with a rear grease trough and a stated 500 sq. in. cooking area. If you are considering a complete cooker instead, compare flat-top gas griddles.
If you meant a cover or lid, choose one of those only to protect your current cooking surface.
The products in this guide serve different jobs: some replace the cooking surface, while others cover it during storage. If you are choosing a complete outdoor cooker, compare natural gas grill and griddle combos.
The 28 inch options below don't guarantee a 36 inch griddle replacement, so use a part made for your grill's exact size and model.
For more surface options across grill types, see our Best Griddle Top guide. If you want to compare cooking on a flat top with cooking on grates, read Is a Griddle Better Than a Grill?.
Our picks at a glance
-
1
-
2
Best for a lightweight coverFlybold 28 Inch Blackstone Griddle Hard Cover
9.6/10 our score
See it on Amazon -
3
Best for listed 28 inch modelsBarbqtime 28 Inch Griddle Replacement Top
9.4/10 our score
See it on Amazon
- 4
Check itBBQration Upgrade Hinged Lid for Blackstone
Best for hands-free cover storage - 5
Check itDELSbbq 5003 Hard Top Lid Cover
Best for several 28 inch brands - 6
Check itStanbroil 28 Inch Stainless Steel Replacement Griddle
Best for stainless steel cooking - 7
Check itBBQration Upgrade 28" Griddle Top for Blackstone
Best for a reinforced back design - 8
Check itStanbroil 28 Inch Non-Stick Replacement Griddle Top
Best for a coated cooking surface
Which Blackstone replacement griddle top fits your model?
The right replacement depends on your model number, grease outlet and hood arrangement, not the 28 inch label alone. The picks below are ordered by their assigned scores, but fit should decide your choice.
We compared the stated materials, dimensions, features and compatibility notes against the needs of someone replacing a 28 inch cooking surface or adding a cover. Our score weighs specs and features against what you're shopping for.
| Product | Best for | Fit | Material | Use | Our score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OZG 28" Premium Silicone Griddle Mat | storage protection | Standard 28 inch Blackstone; not 28 XL | Food-grade silicone | Cover griddle during storage | 9.7 |
| Flybold 28 Inch Blackstone Griddle Hard Cover | a lightweight cover | Designed for 28 inch Blackstone and Member’s Mark griddles | Powder-coated aluminum | 9.6 | |
| Barbqtime 28 Inch Griddle Replacement Top | listed 28 inch models | Alloy steel | 9.4 | ||
| BBQration Upgrade Hinged Lid for Blackstone | hands-free cover storage | Selected 28 inch models; not 28 inch 3-burner XL | 9.3 | ||
| DELSbbq 5003 Hard Top Lid Cover | several 28 inch brands | 28 inch models from several brands | 9.0 | ||
| Stanbroil 28 Inch Stainless Steel Replacement Griddle | stainless steel cooking | Standard 28 inch Blackstone with rear grease system; not 28 inch XL | Stainless steel | 8.7 | |
| BBQration Upgrade 28" Griddle Top for Blackstone | a reinforced back design | Selected 28 inch models; not 28 inch 3-burner XL | 8.5 | ||
| Stanbroil 28 Inch Non-Stick Replacement Griddle Top | a coated cooking surface | Standard 28 inch Blackstone with rear grease system; not 28 inch XL | 8.2 |
OZG 28" Premium Silicone Griddle Mat: Best for storage protection
- Sized for standard 28 inch Blackstone griddles
- Food-grade silicone
- Flexible and foldable
- Not for 28 XL models
A flexible silicone cover for protecting a compatible griddle surface between uses. It is a storage cover, not a cooking surface.
Pros
- Flexible and foldable
- Waterproof and oil-proof surface
- Designed to cover the surface
Cons
- Not for direct cooking
- Not for 28 XL models
The OZG silicone mat protects a compatible 28 inch surface during storage; it does not replace the cooking top. Its food-grade silicone construction is flexible and foldable, and OZG describes it as a cover that helps shield the surface from moisture, dust and debris.
OZG says the mat fits standard 28 inch Blackstone griddles but excludes 28 inch XL models. Check your model before choosing it, especially if your grill is an XL or has an unusual surface shape.
This pick suits you if the old cooking surface is still usable and your main concern is keeping it covered between cooks. It won't help if the metal top itself is damaged or needs replacement.
Flybold 28 Inch Blackstone Griddle Hard Cover: Best for a lightweight cover
- Aluminum hard cover
- Suitcase-style handle
- Dual hangers
- Can serve as a wind guard
A removable hard cover with a handle and dual hangers for storage at the back of the griddle. Flybold says it can also work as a wind guard.
Pros
- Lightweight aluminum cover
- Handle for lifting
- Dual hangers
Cons
- A cover, not a replacement cooking surface
- Confirm the grill model and cover fit
Flybold's aluminum hard cover is another storage option, with a suitcase-style handle and dual hangers for resting the cover at the back of the griddle. Flybold also says the cover can serve as a wind guard during cooking, but it remains a cover rather than the cooking surface.
For another fitted option, see 28-inch Blackstone griddle covers.
The cover is designed for 28 inch Blackstone and Member’s Mark griddles. Its listed dimensions are 29.8 x 19.6 x 2.2 in, so compare the cover shape and your grill setup before buying.
Pick this when you want a removable hard cover with a handle and hangers. If you're shopping for a cooking top, move on to the replacement surfaces below.
Barbqtime 28 Inch Griddle Replacement Top: Best for listed 28 inch models
- 28 x 18 in top
- Rear grease system
- Heavy-duty steel
- Model compatibility list
A steel cooking surface for several named 28 inch Blackstone models. Barbqtime cautions that newer models may not fit and the top may not work with the lid.
Pros
- Rear grease system
- Named model compatibility list
- Handles for moving and positioning
Cons
- Not for newer models, according to Barbqtime
- May not work with a lid
Barbqtime's 28 x 18 in steel top is designed for a group of named Blackstone 28 inch models, including 1517, 1853 and 1883. It has a rear grease system, and its compatibility notes say to check the model and size before buying.
The key caution is hood fit: Barbqtime says the top may not work with the lid and may not fit newer models. That makes this a better candidate when your grill matches a named model and you can confirm the hood clearance.
Before choosing it, compare the old top's dimensions and grease layout, then verify the model number. If the grill has a hood, confirm it can close over this replacement.
BBQration Upgrade Hinged Lid for Blackstone: Best for hands-free cover storage
- Hinged lid for named 28 inch models
- Opens from the front
- Mounting parts included
- Thermometer included
A hinged hood that opens from the front and stays attached instead of needing to be lifted off and hung behind the griddle. It is not compatible with the 28 inch 3-burner XL.
Pros
- Stays attached when opened
- Mounting parts included
- Thermometer included
Cons
- Not for 28 inch 3-burner XL
- Requires a screwdriver for installation
BBQration's hinged lid is a cover upgrade, not a replacement cooking top. It opens from the front and stays attached, which avoids lifting a loose cover off and finding a place to hang it.
BBQration names several compatible 28 inch models, including 1517, 1853, 1605 and 1839, and excludes the 28 inch 3-burner XL. The package includes mounting parts and a thermometer, while installation requires a screwdriver.
Choose it if you want an attached lid for a compatible grill. Check the model and grease arrangement before ordering, and make sure you have the tool needed to install it.
DELSbbq 5003 Hard Top Lid Cover: Best for several 28 inch brands
- Hard cover with two handles
- Two hanging brackets
- Compatible brand examples include Blackstone, Pit Boss, Cuisinart and Charbroil
A removable hard cover with two handles and brackets for hanging it behind the griddle. Compatibility includes selected 28 inch models from several brands.
Pros
- Two handles
- Brackets for hanging
- Several compatible brand examples
Cons
- A cover, not a replacement cooking surface
- Confirm your exact model before choosing
DELSbbq's 5003 is a removable hard cover with two handles and brackets that let it hang behind the griddle when it's not in use. It is designed for 28 inch Blackstone griddles and also names selected 28 inch models from Pit Boss, Cuisinart and Charbroil.
The maker describes the cover as useful for keeping the cooking surface clean between uses and for holding heat while cooking. Since brand compatibility can vary by model, compare your grill's surface and rear hanging setup with the cover before choosing it.
This is a practical choice if you need a hard cover for one of the named 28 inch grills. It won't replace a worn or damaged cooking surface.
Stanbroil 28 Inch Stainless Steel Replacement Griddle: Best for stainless steel cooking
- Stainless steel surface
- Rear grease trough and drain
- 500 sq. in. cooking area
- Not for 28 inch XL models
A stainless steel replacement surface for standard 28 inch Blackstone griddles with a rear grease system. Removable handles help with moving the top.
Pros
- Stainless steel cooking surface
- Rear grease trough and drain
- Removable handles
Cons
- Not for 28 inch XL models
- Requires exact model and grease-system match
The Stanbroil stainless steel top is the clearest cooking-surface replacement among these picks for a standard 28 inch Blackstone with a rear grease system. It has a full-width rear trough and drain, removable handles, and a stated 500 sq. in. cooking area.
Stanbroil says it fits standard 28 inch flat-top grills with a rear grease system, including models with a hood, but excludes 28 inch XL models. That distinction matters because the overall width can look close even when the hood or grease opening differs.
Choose stainless steel if you want that surface material and your grill matches the stated fit. Before ordering, compare the replacement's dimensions with your original top and check the exact model number.
BBQration Upgrade 28" Griddle Top for Blackstone: Best for a reinforced back design
- Designed for named 28 inch models
- Back X-shape design
- Built-in wind protection
- Not for 28 inch 3-burner XL
A replacement top for a range of named 28 inch Blackstone models. BBQration notes that fit with the original hood can vary, so check the model and hood shape.
Pros
- Named model compatibility list
- Back X-shape design
- Built-in wind protection
Cons
- Not for 28 inch 3-burner XL
- Fit with an original hood may vary
BBQration's replacement top is designed for selected 28 inch Blackstone models, including 1517, 1853, 1605 and 1839. It has a back X-shape design and built-in wind protection, while BBQration notes that fit with an original hood can vary.
This top is not for the 28 inch 3-burner XL. BBQration also says to check the grill's appearance and model number, which is useful when a hood or grease setup makes the fit less obvious.
Choose it if your model is among the listed versions and the hood clearance checks out. Compare the grease outlet and top dimensions with your current surface before deciding.
Stanbroil 28 Inch Non-Stick Replacement Griddle Top: Best for a coated cooking surface
- Ceramic-coated surface
- Rear grease trough and drain
- 540 sq. in. stated cooking area
- Not for 28 inch XL models
A steel replacement top with a ceramic-coated cooking surface and rear grease management. Stanbroil lists compatibility with standard 28 inch models, including models with a hood.
Pros
- Ceramic-coated surface
- Rear grease trough and drain
- Removable side handles
Cons
- Not for 28 inch XL models
- Check model and grease-system match
This Stanbroil top has a ceramic-coated cooking surface, rear grease trough and drain, and removable side handles. Stanbroil states a 540 sq. in. cooking area and compatibility with standard 28 inch Blackstone models with a rear grease system, including models with a hood.
It excludes 28 inch XL models, so confirm the model number before choosing it. The coating is the main difference from the stainless steel Stanbroil option above; select based on the surface you want and the fit your grill requires.
The stated cooking area differs from the stainless steel version, but dimensions and compatibility still matter more than that number alone. Check the existing top's footprint and grease layout before you order.
How do I match a replacement top to a 28 inch Blackstone?
Match a replacement top by model number, grease system, dimensions and hood clearance. A 28 inch label describes a size class, not a guarantee that the part fits every grill in that class.
Start with the model number on your grill, then compare it with the replacement's compatibility notes. Barbqtime names many models but cautions that newer versions may not fit, while BBQration excludes 28 inch XL versions from its two replacement tops.
Next, check whether grease drains from the rear or side and whether the hood closes over the top. Measure the old cooking surface and compare its shape, handles and grease outlet with the replacement.
If you need general surface ideas for a gas grill, our Best Griddle Top For Gas Grills guide covers that separate setup. Owners of a Weber Genesis can also see our best griddle for Weber Genesis options.
Is a 36 inch griddle replacement top included here?
No, these are 28 inch products, so they don't serve as a 36 inch griddle replacement. A 36 inch griddle replacement top needs to match the larger grill's model, dimensions and grease system.
Avoid choosing by brand and width alone. Check your grill's model number, the old top's measurements, grease outlet location and any hood clearance before buying a 36 inch part.
If you're comparing different grill styles, our guide to a Best Griddle Top For Kamado Grills explains how those surfaces differ. You can also read How Does A Blackstone Grill Work? for a quick overview of its flat-top cooking setup.
Which replacement or cover should you choose?
Choose the Stanbroil stainless steel top if you have a standard 28 inch Blackstone with a rear grease system and want a stainless cooking surface. Pick the ceramic-coated Stanbroil if that surface is your preference and your model fits.
Choose Barbqtime or BBQration only after checking the named model and hood fit. For storage protection, choose a hard cover or silicone mat, and use a 36 inch replacement made for your exact grill if that's the size you own.
Our top 3 picks at a glance
-
1
-
2
Best for a lightweight cover
Flybold 28 Inch Blackstone Griddle Hard Cover
9.6/10 our score
See it on Amazon -
3
Best for listed 28 inch models
Barbqtime 28 Inch Griddle Replacement Top
9.4/10 our score
See it on Amazon
Frequently asked questions
How do I choose a 28 inch griddle replacement top for Blackstone?
Match the exact model number, grease system, and hood before you buy. Some tops fit standard 28 inch models but exclude 28 inch XL versions, and Barbqtime warns that its top may not work with a lid.
Measure the old surface and compare its shape and grease outlet with the replacement.
Will a 28 inch replacement griddle top fit every Blackstone?
No. The products here name specific compatible models, and several exclude 28 inch XL versions.
A matching width alone does not confirm fit.
Check whether your grill has a rear or side grease system, then compare the model number and hood arrangement with the replacement's compatibility notes.
Can I use a hard cover as a replacement cooking surface?
No. Hard covers and silicone mats protect the cooking surface during storage, while replacement griddle tops are the parts you cook on.
Choose a top if the cooking surface needs replacing.
Choose a cover or mat to help keep the existing surface clean between uses.
What should I check for a 36 inch griddle replacement?
Confirm the exact grill model, cooking-surface dimensions, grease outlet and hood fit before choosing a 36 inch replacement. The replacement tops in this guide are 28 inch options, so they are not a match for a 36 inch grill.
Compare against a dedicated 36 inch griddle replacement top for your model.
